"I mean it's good, I would never complain about it," Portnoy said after sampling the square pie from Brooklyn Original in Haddon Heights.
He rated it a 7.3
Despite the shop boasting its famous square pie, customers said the CEO actually got the "wrong one." Portnoy tried two other styles, which he also gave similar ratings.
Click here to watch the full One Bite review.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Rutherford and receive free news updates.